Skip to main content

Impact factors measure influence, not quality

Share:

Impact factors get brought up sometimes in scientific debates, but many people are not familiar with what they mean. Here are a few basics that help make sense of what a journal impact factor can and cannot tell you.

First, some key terms:

  • Journal: A journal is a publication that regularly releases scientific articles throughout the year, such as original research. There are thousands of different science journals, some of the most popular are Nature, Science, Cell, and The New England Journal of Medicine (7). 
  • Article: A scientific article is a piece of research that is usually published in a peer-reviewed journal. It explains the study’s question, methods, results, and conclusions so other scientists can evaluate the work, critique it, repeat it, or build on it (8,9).

A journal impact factor measures the journal influence (average citations per year). It doesn’t tell you about the influence (or trustworthiness) of a specific article. So, if you want to check whether a study is solid, look at the science itself, not the impact factor.

Sources
  1. Journal Impact Factor: Its Use, Significance and Limitations | World Journal of Nuclear Medicine | May-August 2014
  2. Subject and Course Guides: Measuring Your Impact: Impact Factor, Citation Analysis, and other Metrics: Journal Impact Factor (IF) | University of Illinois Library 
  3. Not-so-deep impact | Nature | June 2005
  4. What a Journal Impact Factor Is and Isn’t | Office for Science and Society – McGill University | January 2024
  5. Impact Factor—a Useful Tool, but Not for All Purposes | Deutsches Arzteblatt International | April 2012
  6. Differences in impact factor across fields and over time | Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology | December 2008
  7. What is a journal article? (What is an article?) | Simon Fraser University Library
  8. Scientific Papers | Scitable by nature education 
  9. What is a Scientific Article? – Biological Sciences Research Guide. | Sam Houston State University – Newton Gresham Library

Share our original Bluesky Post!